Razgovor sa suradnikom:Ame71
Ame71, dobro došli na Wikipediju na hrvatskome jeziku, započetu 16. veljače 2003. godine – slobodnu enciklopediju!
Pozivamo vas na sudjelovanje u rastu ove svima dostupne enciklopedije na hrvatskome standardnom jeziku.
Ovdje su neke od stranica koje bi vam mogle pomoći:
- Wikipedija − što je Wikipedija, povijest i organizacija projekta,
- izvori − kako uspješno činiti Wikipediju boljom, te
- slike − obvezno pročitati prije postavljanja bilo kakvih slika.
Ako želite vježbati možete to raditi na stranici za vježbanje, u slučaju da vam zatreba pomoć učinite sljedeće:
- postavite pitanje u Kafiću, odgovor će brzo stići,
- spojite se na IRC (chat): #wikipedia-hr.
Svoje doprinose na člancima ne potpisujte, dok komentare na pripadajućim stranicama za razgovor, suradničkim stranicama i Kafiću molimo potpisujte tako što ćete pritisnuti gumbić ili na alatnoj vrpci ili napisati 4 tilde (tilda = 4x istovremeno tipke AltGr + tipka s brojem 1), što kod uređivanja izgleda ovako ~~~~.
Vlastitu suradničku stranicu (onu koja se zove "Suradnik:Ame71") možete uređivati po svojoj želji u skladu s pravilima uređivanja suradničke stranice (npr. asketski ili šminkerski).
Molimo Vas, ne stavljajte zaštićene radove bez dopuštenja! Nemojte izravno kopirati sadržaje s drugih internetskih stranica ako nemate izričito dopuštenje. Ako imate dopuštenje, napišite to na stranici za razgovor ili jednostavno dodajte ovdje. No, obvezno to napravite prije nego započnete s pisanjem preuzetog teksta. Molimo uočite da se svi doprinosi Wikipediji smatraju dvojno licencirani, pod Creative Commons Imenovanje-Dijeli pod istim uvjetima 3.0 i GFDL licencijom. Ako ne želite da se vaše pisanje nemilosrdno uređuje i slobodno raspačava, nemojte ga ovamo slati. Također nam obećavate da ćete ono što ćete napisati sami napisati, ili ćete to prepisati iz nečeg što je u javnom vlasništvu ili pod sličnom slobodnom licencijom.
If you don't speak Croatian: This is a welcome message sent to new users of hr.wikipedia.
Još jednom, dobro došli! --Tulkas Astaldo (razgovor) 16:20, 22. veljače 2019. (CET)
Hrvatska liga - Istok
[uredi kôd]Hvala ti zbilja što stavljaštablice liga, za vrijeme FNRJ/SFRJ.
Samo, bili mi ostavio da ja dovršim sezone Hrvatske lige - Istok, s obzirom da imam dosta izvora za ove zsezone (razne monografdije klubova), ali nikako da to završim.... (a bio sam dosta toga stavio negdje 2020. i početak 2021.)
baš Sportnet-ov forum admini mogu opovrgnuti kao izvor...
samo nastavi, a možeš mi ostaviti i mail, pa ti pošaljem materijala, ili vež nekako....
Srdačan pozfdrav, Cybermb (razgovor) 23:40, 7. rujna 2022. (CEST)
Dobro došli na Wikipediju na hrvatskome jeziku! Slobodno se predstavite na vašoj suradničkoj stranici. Popunite je suradničkim okvirima i upišite nazive članaka koje ste započeli ili planirate stvoriti. Feel free to write something about yourself on your user page. You can also add userboxes. |
Lijepo te pozdravlja, Koreanovsky (Ča–Kaj–Što?!) 08:47, 8. rujna 2022. (CEST)
Re:Hrvatska liga - Istok
[uredi kôd]Napravit ću, ti samo nastavi, ja ću nadopisati izvore ako ti nemaš,
staviti ću punu tablicu, ali danas neću moći...vjerojatnije u subotu (10.09.)
Cybermb (razgovor) 13:01, 8. rujna 2022. (CEST)
Jezik
[uredi kôd]Dobro došli na Wikipediju! Drago nam je što doprinosite Wikipediji, no skrećemo pozornost na činjenicu da je službeni jezik na hrvatskoj Wikipediji − hrvatski jezik. Želite li pisati na nekom drugom jeziku, molimo vas odaberite odgovarajuću inačicu Wikipedije gdje je taj jezik službeni. Hvala na razumijevanju.--Tulkas Astaldo (razgovor) 23:55, 8. srpnja 2023. (CEST)
Prečesto snimanje
[uredi kôd]Ame, nama bi pomoglo kad ne bi snimao baš svaku izmjenu svake 2 minute. Softver će kod tebe u pregledniku sačuvati izmjene čak i ako se sve sruši. Jednom u 10-15 minuta je OK. Imaš sad u uređivaču tipku koja ti pokazuje stranicu u stvarnom vremenu dok je uredjujes. Tipka je, mislim, gore desno. Podijelit će prozor na dva dijela. ponor (razgovor) 19:12, 30. kolovoza 2023. (CEST)
- @Ponor, suradnik je s it.wiki i nisam siguran da razumije hrvatski. Ame71, today I wanted to ask you if you spoke Croatian. If not, I am really impressed by the state of Google Translate's translations or whatever translator you're using. – Croxyz 💬 19:37, 30. kolovoza 2023. (CEST)
- Vidim da je Ame već mogao biti samoophođen, ali nisam aktivirao: Wikipedija:Prijedlozi za dodjelu prava/Arhiv 2022#Ame71. ponor (razgovor) 19:40, 30. kolovoza 2023. (CEST)
- Bok, ja sam Talijan i uglavnom radim na it.wiki. Supruga mi je Hrvatica, a ja znam izgovoriti jednostavne rečenice na hrvatskom jeziku, za one složenije koristim prevoditelj. Iz tog razloga se posvećujem tablicama na hr.wiki. —Ame71 (razgovor). 20:39, 30. kolovoza 2023. (CEST)
- Ame, sve je to u redu. Mi tebe još patroliramo, a kada često snimaš netko mora i po 100 puta stisnuti "patrol". Slobodno uređuj tablice (i sve drugo), samo nemoj snimati toliko često. (vidi: m:Community Wishlist Survey 2021/Real Time Preview for Wikitext - Preview = Pretpregled) Možda ću te promovirati u autopatrolled, vidjet ću još. Sretno, ponor (razgovor) 14:46, 31. kolovoza 2023. (CEST)
FK Kolubara Lazarevac
[uredi kôd]ja sam počeo raditi članak FK Kolubara Lazarevac, a sad vidim da na tvojoj stranici za vježbanje si počeo pripremu za članak za isti klub. Već kad sam stvorio članak, mogu li iskoristiti išta od tvog teksta, te da ga dalje uređujem kako inače radim članke o nogometnim klubovima?
Srdačan pozdrav
Cybermb (razgovor) 08:30, 3. siječnja 2024. (CET)
- OK, nastavim ja s Kolubarom, bilo bi bolje da članak bude FK Srem Srijemska Mitrovica, a potom stvoriš FK Srem Sremska Mitrovica pa njegovo preusmjerenje na FK Srem Srijemska Mitrovica
- imam neki plan dugoročno stvoriti članke za preostale klubove koji su se natjecali u Superligi Srbije, a vidim da ti radiš za one koji su se natjecali u drugoj saveznoj ligi SFRJ/FNRJ
- Vjerojatno si primijetio da u Kategorija:Srbijanski nogometni klubovi ukoliko smo radili podkategorije za klubove po okruzima Srbije ukoliko imamo tri ili više kluba po okrugu
- Samo nastavi
- Cybermb (razgovor) 09:34, 3. siječnja 2024. (CET)
- Ovo za Prvu saveznu ligu' (a i kasnije Međurepubličke i još nešto, pa dosta ljestvica 1. HNL, 2. HNL i još neke lige) je rađeno uglavnom negdje 2007.- 2009. i nije baš dirano otad, ima grešaka, tad se moglo "i bez izvora". Tablice su tad rađene uglavnom preko zaglavlja/stila/predloška prettytable , mislim da je wikitable kasnije uveden, i još za svaku ćeliju je išlo u jedan red po kodu, (mjesto da jedan red tablice bude u 1-2 reda koda), nešto sam bio uređivao, ali sam uglavnom odustao, ima dosta posla oko toga, pa dok "stoji - stoji".
- Cybermb (razgovor) 10:10, 3. siječnja 2024. (CET)
Sezone Prve savezne lige - klubovi
[uredi kôd]Super što radiš članke za sezone Prve savezne lige, kao Prva savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1953./54., Prva savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1964./65., odnosno vidljivo iz tvojih započetih stranica
Međutim, primijetio sam da u tablicama, malo nekonzistetno stavljaš klubove, uz neke stavljaš grad iz kojeg su ( Dinamo Zagreb, Hajduk Split, Radnički Beograd, Proleter Osijek, Sutjeska Nikšić, itd.), ali za druge ne stavljaš gradove, iako je to na hr. wikipediji (pa i u medijima) uobičajeno (odnosno Crvena zvezda mjesto Crvena zvezda Beograd, Partizan mjesto Partizan Beograd, Vojvodina mjesto Vojvodina Novi Sad, Željezničar mjesto Željezničar Sarajevo, Budućnost mjesto Budućnost Titograd - ispod staviti napomenu da je Titograd tadašnji naziv za Podgoricu, itd.)
Pa ako možeš to malo izmijeni i za buduće članke probaš tako, da se ne mora naknadno ispravljati....(naravno ako je ime greada vidljivo iz samog imena kluba...ostaviš kako jest - Rijeka, Sarajevo, Maribor, Osijek, Bor, Novi Sad, itd..)
Pozdrav, Cybermb (razgovor) 07:29, 5. veljače 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb Gledao sam kako izgledaju neke druge stranice na hr.wiki pa sam "Crvena zvezda" i "Partizan" napisao bez grada. U redu, dodat ću ga sa sljedeće stranice. U it.wiki smo navikli ne uključivati grad ako je tim poznat.--Ame71 (razgovor). 08:47, 5. veljače 2024. (CET)
- primijetio sam na en.wiki, primjerice 1961–62 Yugoslav First League, ali ako ideš po starim izmjenama (od 2005.), vidi se da su mijenjali oblik i sadržaj tablica
- naravno, i mi na hr.wiki smo malo nekonzistetni - primjer HNL 2022./23.
- ali možeš vidjeti kako radim ljestvice za najviše lige ostalih HRV prvenstava u drugim športovima, primjerice Superliga Hrvatske u odbojci za žene 2021./22., ali prvenstvo se igra liga, pa potom doigravanje; ili 1. HRL za žene 2021./22. - igra se sasmo ligaški dio - uglavnom u početnom odjeljku klubovi (sa sjedištima / gradovima), a u ljestvici samo nazivi klubova (bez imena gradova / sjedišta...)
- Cybermb (razgovor) 09:41, 5. veljače 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb Napravio sam stranicu Prva savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1965./66. ostavljajući neke timove (Crvena zvezda, Partizan, itd.) kao i do sada. Ubacio sam popis sudionika i kartu kao i vi u 1. HRL za žene 2021./22.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:09, 7. veljače 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb Imam problem: u karti SCG na stranici Prva liga SR Jugoslavije u nogometu 1995./96. u blizini su tri grada. Volio bih Mladost Lučani staviti na “top” ili “bottom”, ali ne mogu. Kako mogu napraviti? --Ame71 (razgovor). 16:48, 26. ožujka 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb Napravio sam stranicu Prva savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1965./66. ostavljajući neke timove (Crvena zvezda, Partizan, itd.) kao i do sada. Ubacio sam popis sudionika i kartu kao i vi u 1. HRL za žene 2021./22.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:09, 7. veljače 2024. (CET)
- meni se to također povremeno događalo, ovo sa "top" i "bototm" se i meni događalo da mi uopće ne prikaže dobro, ili izbaci poziciju dalje od željene. Stoga su se i meni događala takva preklapanja kao 2. HNL 2020./21. ili A1 liga Košarkaškog saveza Herceg-Bosne 2017./18. - po meni bolje staviti kao nekakav naziv i onda sa strane (kao što si radio sa BG klubovima, pa da izgleda kao nešto ovako: Superliga Hrvatske u odbojci za žene 2021./22.
- Cybermb (razgovor) 07:43, 28. ožujka 2024. (CET)
Pitanje
[uredi kôd]Nije mi jasno zašto ste ovdje dodali tu kategoriju kad ta državna zajednica tada još nije bila osnovana?--Tulkas Astaldo (razgovor) 08:21, 21. ožujka 2024. (CET)
- @Tulkas Astaldo Učinio sam to jer je na stranici Prva liga Srbije i Crne Gore u nogometu bila i sezona 1991./92.--Ame71 (razgovor). 09:18, 21. ožujka 2024. (CET)
- Razumijem. Međutim, recimo ovdje se navodi da je državna prvenstva Zvezda 1994./95., 1999./00., 2000./01. osvojila u SR Jugoslaviji, a 2003./04., 2005./06. u Srbiji i Crnoj Gori, što mi je i logično. Dakle, ne vidim razloga za preklapanje tih dvaju natjecanja, tj ne vidim razloga za ovu promjenu. Imate li neki razlog za navedenu promjenu osim ovog koji ste gore naveli? — Prethodni nepotpisani komentar napisao je Tulkas Astaldo (razgovor • doprinosi)
- @Tulkas Astaldo Ne, nemam drugih razloga, samo sam to učinio da se uskladim sa spomenutom stranicom. Nema problema s poništavanjem moje promjene.--Ame71 (razgovor). 05:16, 22. ožujka 2024. (CET)
- Razumijem. Međutim, recimo ovdje se navodi da je državna prvenstva Zvezda 1994./95., 1999./00., 2000./01. osvojila u SR Jugoslaviji, a 2003./04., 2005./06. u Srbiji i Crnoj Gori, što mi je i logično. Dakle, ne vidim razloga za preklapanje tih dvaju natjecanja, tj ne vidim razloga za ovu promjenu. Imate li neki razlog za navedenu promjenu osim ovog koji ste gore naveli? — Prethodni nepotpisani komentar napisao je Tulkas Astaldo (razgovor • doprinosi)
Frequent saving
[uredi kôd]Ciao Ame71. Last August I asked for the reasons for your frequent saves, but somehow we never got the answer. The thing is, you're not autopatrolled on this wiki (because you're, obviously, not a native speaker), which means that for your every save someone needs to open up the diff and mark the change as patrolled (see here). That's some 50 to 100 patroller actions every day! I don't see why anyone would save every minute change, as the software will recover them even if your browser crashes (there's a user preferences setting for that). I kindly ask you to save less frequently. That's what we expect from all our users — {{NS-prikaži1}} {{NS-prikaži2}} {{NS-prikaži!}}. Another option is to treat you as autopatrolled, but you'll have to promise you'll only work in your own sandbox(es), and report all mainspace edits to Croxyz, who's been kind enough to copy edit your articles. I hope you understand. Let me know which option you like better. Sincerely, ponor (razgovor) 03:54, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- @Ponor You're right, but I'm doing it only in my sandbox. I don't use this way in creating new pages or modifying others... --Ame71 (razgovor). 04:05, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- It's all the same to our patrollers, we need to patrol every change. Imagine having to press the same button 100 times in a day just to remove your sandbox edits from our unpatrolled edits list.
- Preferenze → Abilita la funzione Edit Recovery. Or option #2: only work in your sandbox, I'll promote you, but communicate every article change to Croxyz. ponor (razgovor) 04:16, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- @Ponor Just did it.--Ame71 (razgovor). 04:25, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- OK. I hate to ask for this, but we have to be mindful of our patrollers' time. I hope you understand. Were you a native speaker, none of this would be a problem, but Croxyz complained about having to work on your articles and I cannot make you autopatrolled any momre. Really, really sorry! ponor (razgovor) 04:33, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- @Ponor Ok.--Ame71 (razgovor). 04:53, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- OK. I hate to ask for this, but we have to be mindful of our patrollers' time. I hope you understand. Were you a native speaker, none of this would be a problem, but Croxyz complained about having to work on your articles and I cannot make you autopatrolled any momre. Really, really sorry! ponor (razgovor) 04:33, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
- @Ponor Just did it.--Ame71 (razgovor). 04:25, 23. lipnja 2024. (CEST)
Newfound tables/participating clubs
[uredi kôd]If I have the time and energy, I'll make a list of every table that's currently missing on it./hr.wiki that I found online. As mentioned previously, I managed to find some tables from lower tier Bosnia and Herzegovina and Vojvodina clubs. Right now I managed to find some lower tier Serbian tables. Do you know Cyrillic? If not I can latinise the tables for you. – Croxyz 💬 23:57, 4. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Here's what I managed to find tonight:
- Source: Milorad Sijić, FK Napredak, Kragujevac, 2020.
- Kragujevačka zona 1960./61. (Kragujevac zone), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1960./61. (page 66)
- Kragujevačka zona 1961./62. (Kragujevac zone), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1961./62. (page 69)
- Srpska liga – Jug 1962./63. (Serbian league – South), only features table of Srpska liga – Jug A (Srpska liga – Jug B is missing, the text says that the Serbian league hasd 2 groups), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1962./63.??? (page 73)
- Srpska liga – Jug 1963./64. (Serbian league – South), only features table of Srpska liga – Jug A (Srpska liga – Jug B and C are missing) (page 77), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1963./64., compare with it:Zonske lige 1963-1964 (needs to be compared to forum post)
- Srpska liga – Jug 1964./65. (Serbian league – South) (page 83), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1964./65., it:Zonske lige 1964-1965 is missing this table
- Srpska liga – Jug 1965./66. (Serbian league – South) (page 88), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1965./66., see it:Zonske lige 1965-1966 (needs to be compared to forum post)
- Srpska liga – Jug 1966./67. (Serbian league – South) (page 92), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1966./67., it:Zonske lige 1966-1967 is missing this table
- Srpska liga – Jug 1967./68. (Serbian league – South) (page 97), part of Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1967./68., see it:Zonske lige 1967-1968 (needs to be compared to forum post)
- – Croxyz 💬 00:26, 5. rujna 2024. (CEST)
P.S. I don't know if I ever sent you this (missing seasons from NK Maksimir's website which you used in the past):
Name of league/season | New article? | Should be added to | Source |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1926./27. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1926./27. | [1] |
III. A razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1927./28. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1927./28. | [2] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1928./29. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1928./29. | [3] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1929./30. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1929./30. | [4] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1930./31. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1930./31. | [5] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1931./32. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1931./32. | [6] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1932./33. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1932./33. | [7] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1933./34. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1933./34. | [8] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1934./35. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1934./35. | [9] |
III. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1935./36. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1935./36. | [10] |
II. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1936./37. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1936./37. | [11] |
II. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1937./38. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1937./38. | [12] |
II. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1938./39. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1938./39. | [13] |
I. B razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1939./40. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1939./40. | [14] |
II. razred Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1940./41. | – | Prvenstvo Zagrebačkog nogometnog podsaveza 1940./41. | [15] |
II. razred nogometnog Prvenstva Zagreba 1951. | II. razred nogometnog Prvenstva Zagreba 1951. | – | [16] |
Vrbas has two books: [17][18] which contain missing Vojvodina seasons (mentioned previously).
Željezničar also has a book ([[19]]). I didn't check if any of the pre-WW2 seasons were missing. All post WW2 seasons are documented on Wiki. – Croxyz 💬 00:43, 5. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz It's good, now i'm improving the pages of 2nd dvision, then I'll manage the 3rd one. Thanks for the links.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:00, 5. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- These past few days I've slowly been building Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori, an uncomplete list of online resources for Yugoslav football history. A large percentage of these have been found in your and Cybermb's articles, although keep in mind that I haven't listed all sources since I don't know them. Fell free to expand the list for us and future use (future editors and readers). I might publish this list once somewhere else with a different name. I've started compiling it several days ago to assist you with articles on 3rd and 4th divisions. I've noticed that a lot of seasons are missing on Croatian and Italian Wikis (especially pre-WW2 ones). I wrote several of these seasons these past few days. I'll probably write only a portion of the post-WW2 seasons from Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. I plan on focusing seasons from here since a lot of seasons are missing (and possibly a table for FK Budućnost Banovići). – Croxyz 💬 21:34, 20. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz Well done, it will be useful for me when i'll improve the 3rd division pages.--Ame71 (razgovor). 22:58, 20. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- These past few days I've slowly been building Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori, an uncomplete list of online resources for Yugoslav football history. A large percentage of these have been found in your and Cybermb's articles, although keep in mind that I haven't listed all sources since I don't know them. Fell free to expand the list for us and future use (future editors and readers). I might publish this list once somewhere else with a different name. I've started compiling it several days ago to assist you with articles on 3rd and 4th divisions. I've noticed that a lot of seasons are missing on Croatian and Italian Wikis (especially pre-WW2 ones). I wrote several of these seasons these past few days. I'll probably write only a portion of the post-WW2 seasons from Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. I plan on focusing seasons from here since a lot of seasons are missing (and possibly a table for FK Budućnost Banovići). – Croxyz 💬 21:34, 20. rujna 2024. (CEST)
Sveti/Sveta/Sveto
[uredi kôd]I just wanted to share one of my experiences dealing with modern sources. I commonly find sources (e.g. Sveta Klara in this source: [20]) that mention placenames that include the words Sveti/Sveta/Sveto (saint in m./f./n. gender). In post-WW2 Yugoslavia (and other socialist states) the words Sveti/Sveta/Sveto were dropped from placenames. These names were sometimes additionally changed (e.g. Sveti Ivan Zelina was called Zelina). – Croxyz 💬 00:32, 19. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I didn't know that, but I'm not surprised. Also ethnical or bourgeois names disappeared. As after 1991 disappeared the "Tito" ones (example Titov Vrbas, Titova Mitrovica...).--Ame71 (razgovor). 06:57, 19. rujna 2024. (CEST)
Errors on Italian Wikipedia
[uredi kôd]The 3rd placed club on it:Zonske lige 1968-1969#Tuzla is listed as Jedinstvo Odžak. The source simply lists it as Jedinstvo. The club in question is Jedinstvo Brčko (for some reason the club wasn't promoted even though it won the league in the past season). The winner of it:Zonske lige 1969-1970#Tuzla is listed as Jedinstvo Odžak instead of Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi (some sources list it as Jedinstvo Novi Grad which is an incorrect name as the city was called Bosnaski Novi prior to the collapse of Yugoslavia). I can't find information about the club on the internet (probably defunct or renamed). It played in Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1961./62. where it was falsely listed as Jedinstvo Novi Grad up to a few minutes ago. I found these errors by using this website. So far I haven't seen any other errors which makes the forum posts reliable/trustworthy. I think it would be the best that you correct the errors since I don't know in which articles it could be present (e.g. on the history sections of clubs that participated in the league those seasons or in tables like NK Maksimir's). – Croxyz 💬 12:59, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- In places such as it:Zonske lige 1970-1971#Tuzla Borac Šamac should be referred to as Borac Bosanski Šamac. The name of this city was also changed, just like Bosanski Novi's. – Croxyz 💬 13:02, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I forgot to mention that according to this website it:Zonske lige 1968-1969#Tuzla should be called Grupa A Prve zone (the site calls it A grupa Prve zone which is grammatically incorrect). Grupa A Prve zone is translated in English as Group A of the First zone. 2. LEGA NORD is likely the first zone with this league (the Tuzla one) being group A. Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori might provide information on other group names (didn't check it as I am busy checking the factual correctness of Italian Wikipedia tables). During the next seasons (see Italian Wikipedia) the league is called Bosansko-sjeveroistočna zona (Bosnian-northeast zone and not Northeastern Bosnian zone). – Croxyz 💬 13:14, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- We should also correct these names on Croatian Wikipedia (for example in the 2nd division season articles). – Croxyz 💬 13:17, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Do you know which division (e.g. 3rd, 4th, 5th etc.) is Sjeveroistočna zona 1973./74.? It isn't listed on it:Zonske lige 1972-1973. – Croxyz 💬 13:48, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz Sjeveroistočna zona 1973./74. was the 4th level as in summer 1973 Jedinstvena BiH liga was formed. Thanks for Jedinstvo Odžak/Brčko : I corrected that. About Borac Bosanski Šamac, do you think I'd have to change in "Borac B. Šamac" till 1991 and "Borac Šamac" later? I can change the template (predložak) of the club in it.wiki. I know the change of the league name in "Grupa A Prve zone", but I prefered to keep going with "Tuzlanska zona" because it's easier to understand for an Italian.--Ame71 (razgovor). 18:03, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I'm not sure about what year to use for (Bosanski) Šamac. I tried looking for a source but found nothing except the first sentence of sh:Šamac (1992). – Croxyz 💬 20:41, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Are you sure that NK Odžak 102 and Jedinstvo Odžak are the same club? – Croxyz 💬 22:58, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I thought they are, aren't they? I haven't found other clubs in Odžak, so I thought they were the same club.--Ame71 (razgovor). 06:54, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz in this page an user says "U Bosanskom Novom nije nikad postojalo Jedinstvo.PRVAK ove lige je najvjerovatnije bilo Jedinstvo iz Odzaka!!!!". I don't know if it's true, but I see Bosanski Novi town was in Banjalučka zona, not Tuzlanska one.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:19, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz In the end of the 50's I see Bih republican leagues were renamed "zone": in 1958 Banja Luka and Tuzla were the 1st zone, Zenica and Sarajevo the 2nd, Hercegovina the 3rd. In 1959 Banja Luka-Tuzla was the 2nd zone and Zenica-Sarajevo the 1st one. If Tuzlanska zona in 1968./69. was "Grupa A Prve zone", I suppose Sarajevo was "Grupa B Prve zone", Banja Luka "Grupa A Druge zone", Tuzla "Grupa B Druge zone" and Hercegovina "Trece zone". But I can't find the sources.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:35, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- bs.wiki has this article: bs:FK Jedinstvo Odžak. The club has a Facebook profile. Looks like today it's a club for kids. – Croxyz 💬 21:37, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- According to Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi (Novi Grad) did in fact exist according to the forum source. @Cybermb might check the other source, Godišnjak Fudbalskog saveza Jugoslavije 1960-61, if he still owns it. – Croxyz 💬 21:51, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Cybermb's table in Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1961./62. contains Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi (Novi Grad). The table is made from 2 sources. – Croxyz 💬 23:39, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- At the moment I am writing FK Budućnost Banovići's table. What should I call the 1952./53. season? – Croxyz 💬 00:41, 25. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Also keep in mind that I created all of these articles presented in the table from already existing articles and the club's own website. I haven't used the SportSport.ba forum (Ligaški vremeplov) at all. If you want, fell free to find the missing season and complete info for seasons like Međuopćinska nogometna liga Tuzla 1978./79. – Croxyz 💬 01:07, 25. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- On the forum I found the name of the 1952./53. season. It seems that the club created its pages based on the SportSport.ba forum (Ligaški vremeplov) meaning that some of the seasons have uncompleted tables! No wonder the club's website calls its history section Vremeplov. This explains the Jedinstvo Odžak/Bosanski Novi problem. Looks like I'll have to check every article to see if it has a complete table. Here's a list of forum pages for seasons that currently don't reference it (some seasons are listed repeatedly, I only listed the first appearence of each season):
- Oblasna liga Tuzla 1950. [21]
- Sjeveroistočna nogometna zona 1973./74. [22]
- Regionalna nogometna liga BiH – Sjever 1979./80. [23]
- Međuopćinska nogometna liga Tuzla 1978./79. [24]
- Regionalna nogometna liga BiH – Sjever 1980./81. [25]
- Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 4. ligaški rang 1953./54. [26] The goal-difference is wrong. A disclamer should be put here.
- Podsavezna nogometna liga Tuzla 1959./60. [27]
- Međupodsavezna nogometna liga Brčko – Doboj – Tuzla 1963./64. [28]
- Međupodsavezna nogometna liga Brčko – Doboj – Tuzla 1965./66. [29]
- Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1956./57. [30] Our current table is incomplete
- 1958./59. (missing season) [31]
- – Croxyz 💬 02:46, 25. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I actually don't know what to call the 1952/53 season for Budućnost Banovići. Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1952./53. + forum link – Croxyz 💬 00:20, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- The 1959/60 table confuses me. Why would teams in a 9 team league play 17 matches instead of 16? Could have a club quit midseason? – Croxyz 💬 17:24, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1966./67. is missing from the list above. I'll have to find it later. – Croxyz 💬 18:03, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I just saw that 1 leg is missing in the 1959/60 season. I assume a club is missing in that table because If a club quitted they'd still be a part of the table. – Croxyz 💬 20:38, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I managed to find the 1966/67 season. – Croxyz 💬 20:46, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I've completed all of Budućnost Banovići's seasons. All that is left is the Jedinstvo Odžak/Bosanski Novi issue (still waiting for @Cybermb to check his sources), the 1959/60 season issue and what to call the 1952/53 season. I don't know how to answer any of those problems. – Croxyz 💬 23:12, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I managed to find the 1966/67 season. – Croxyz 💬 20:46, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- The 1959/60 table confuses me. Why would teams in a 9 team league play 17 matches instead of 16? Could have a club quit midseason? – Croxyz 💬 17:24, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I actually don't know what to call the 1952/53 season for Budućnost Banovići. Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1952./53. + forum link – Croxyz 💬 00:20, 26. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- On the forum I found the name of the 1952./53. season. It seems that the club created its pages based on the SportSport.ba forum (Ligaški vremeplov) meaning that some of the seasons have uncompleted tables! No wonder the club's website calls its history section Vremeplov. This explains the Jedinstvo Odžak/Bosanski Novi problem. Looks like I'll have to check every article to see if it has a complete table. Here's a list of forum pages for seasons that currently don't reference it (some seasons are listed repeatedly, I only listed the first appearence of each season):
- Also keep in mind that I created all of these articles presented in the table from already existing articles and the club's own website. I haven't used the SportSport.ba forum (Ligaški vremeplov) at all. If you want, fell free to find the missing season and complete info for seasons like Međuopćinska nogometna liga Tuzla 1978./79. – Croxyz 💬 01:07, 25. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- At the moment I am writing FK Budućnost Banovići's table. What should I call the 1952./53. season? – Croxyz 💬 00:41, 25. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Cybermb's table in Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1961./62. contains Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi (Novi Grad). The table is made from 2 sources. – Croxyz 💬 23:39, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- According to Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi (Novi Grad) did in fact exist according to the forum source. @Cybermb might check the other source, Godišnjak Fudbalskog saveza Jugoslavije 1960-61, if he still owns it. – Croxyz 💬 21:51, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- bs.wiki has this article: bs:FK Jedinstvo Odžak. The club has a Facebook profile. Looks like today it's a club for kids. – Croxyz 💬 21:37, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz In the end of the 50's I see Bih republican leagues were renamed "zone": in 1958 Banja Luka and Tuzla were the 1st zone, Zenica and Sarajevo the 2nd, Hercegovina the 3rd. In 1959 Banja Luka-Tuzla was the 2nd zone and Zenica-Sarajevo the 1st one. If Tuzlanska zona in 1968./69. was "Grupa A Prve zone", I suppose Sarajevo was "Grupa B Prve zone", Banja Luka "Grupa A Druge zone", Tuzla "Grupa B Druge zone" and Hercegovina "Trece zone". But I can't find the sources.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:35, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz in this page an user says "U Bosanskom Novom nije nikad postojalo Jedinstvo.PRVAK ove lige je najvjerovatnije bilo Jedinstvo iz Odzaka!!!!". I don't know if it's true, but I see Bosanski Novi town was in Banjalučka zona, not Tuzlanska one.--Ame71 (razgovor). 07:19, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I thought they are, aren't they? I haven't found other clubs in Odžak, so I thought they were the same club.--Ame71 (razgovor). 06:54, 23. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Are you sure that NK Odžak 102 and Jedinstvo Odžak are the same club? – Croxyz 💬 22:58, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I'm not sure about what year to use for (Bosanski) Šamac. I tried looking for a source but found nothing except the first sentence of sh:Šamac (1992). – Croxyz 💬 20:41, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz Sjeveroistočna zona 1973./74. was the 4th level as in summer 1973 Jedinstvena BiH liga was formed. Thanks for Jedinstvo Odžak/Brčko : I corrected that. About Borac Bosanski Šamac, do you think I'd have to change in "Borac B. Šamac" till 1991 and "Borac Šamac" later? I can change the template (predložak) of the club in it.wiki. I know the change of the league name in "Grupa A Prve zone", but I prefered to keep going with "Tuzlanska zona" because it's easier to understand for an Italian.--Ame71 (razgovor). 18:03, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Do you know which division (e.g. 3rd, 4th, 5th etc.) is Sjeveroistočna zona 1973./74.? It isn't listed on it:Zonske lige 1972-1973. – Croxyz 💬 13:48, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- We should also correct these names on Croatian Wikipedia (for example in the 2nd division season articles). – Croxyz 💬 13:17, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I forgot to mention that according to this website it:Zonske lige 1968-1969#Tuzla should be called Grupa A Prve zone (the site calls it A grupa Prve zone which is grammatically incorrect). Grupa A Prve zone is translated in English as Group A of the First zone. 2. LEGA NORD is likely the first zone with this league (the Tuzla one) being group A. Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori might provide information on other group names (didn't check it as I am busy checking the factual correctness of Italian Wikipedia tables). During the next seasons (see Italian Wikipedia) the league is called Bosansko-sjeveroistočna zona (Bosnian-northeast zone and not Northeastern Bosnian zone). – Croxyz 💬 13:14, 22. rujna 2024. (CEST)
@Cybermb Between Jedinstvo Odžak/Bosanski Novi I think it was Odžak, because it's in north-east: the Tuzla and Doboj zone. Bosanski Novi is in north-west, an Jedisntvo B.N. would play in Banja Luka zone leagues. In these days i was working in it.wiki about HNK Borovo and NK Šparta Beli Manastir pages. Borovo was liquidated in 2018? I can't find it after that year. And why NK Šparta has no voice in hr.wiki? Anyway I can't find it after 2020, so I think it's been liquidated. Do you know anything?--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:05, 27. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Cybermb what's the right version: FK Pelister Bitola or FK Pelister Bitolj?
- @Ame71 and @Croxyz, I have some tables from Godišnjak FSJ 1960-1961
- for Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. at the 9th position is staded Jedinstvo (N. G.) - probably is wrong Bosanski Novi - it's a more western than Doboj area.
- in book Vladimir Ravlić: Priča o jednoj Mladosti --- : nogometni klub "Mladost" Modran : 1952. – 2012. : monografija, Zagreb, 2012., ISBN 978-953-98328-0-1, there is staded Jedinstvo (Novi Grad) (again shown as Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi, but my first version of article, created January 30th, 2019,
- I think it could be Novi Grad in Odžak municipality, which is in Bosanska Posavina region, and Doboj is also near
- Look posavinasport.com, Spisak ekipa koje su se postojale u nekadašnjem Brčko i Doboj savezu- 1985 sezona., at Odzak clubs is shown Jedinstvo Novi Grad also
- Bitola was common name for Bitolj used during Yugoslavia period, but nowdays, in Croatian it's more common stated as Bitolj
- Hrvatski obiteljski leksikon
- Proleksis enciklopedija
- Hrvatski jezični portal
- Cybermb (razgovor) 15:47, 27. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Ame71 & @Cybermb, I couldn't find anything on Borovo past 7. rang HNL-a 2018./19.#NS Vukovar. The club probably (temporarily) stopped existing. As for NK Šparta Beli Manastir, it's simple: nobody wrote an article about the club. Serbo-Croatian wiki surprisingly has an article (it was written by a new user). I discourage translating it since it contains grammatical errors and zero sources. Lots of football clubs from Croatia do not have articles. Believe it or not two clubs that played in Croatia's 2nd division in the 90s didn't have articles up until amonth ago when I wrote them (NK Posavina Zagreb & NK Mladost-Nada Hrastovac) even though they were part of a template present in 37 different articles featuring current and previous Croatian 2nd tier sides (Predložak:2. HNL). Posavina's fate is similar to that of Borovo's – it is unknown. I changed back all three instances of "Jedinstvo Bosanski Novi" back to "Jedinstvo Novi Grad", since "Godišnjak 1960-61" is proof that a club called "Jedinstvo Novi Grad" did in fact exist as the name change occured in the 90s. A book published in 1961 obviously couldn't have used a name coined three decades later. – Croxyz 💬 01:12, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Grupa A Prve zone 1969./70. could've been won by Jedinstvo Odžak instead of Novi Grad although we don't have good sources. This site talking about Odžak states: U sezoni 1969.-70. Jedinstvo kao prvak „Tuzlanske zone“, igra neuspješno kvalifikacije sa FK „Galenika“ Zemun, za ulazak u II. saveznu ligu NS Jugoslavije. Iste godine momčad iz Odžaka osvaja titulu amaterskog prvaka BiH. Serbian wiki references this blogpost which states: Posle osvojene titule prvaka severne grupe Srpske lige,Galenici je do plasmana u severnu grupu Druge savezne lige preostao jos kvalifikacioni meč sa prvoplasiranom ekipom severne grupe Lige BiH,Jedinstvom iz Odžaka. Galenika je Jedinstvo pobedila i u Odžacima i u Zemunu i tako ušla na velika vrata u Drugu saveznu ligu. Sadly the history page on the club's website makes no mention of Jedinstvo. On the SportSport.ba forum I found: Tačna je i ispravka da Jedisntvo nije iz Bosanskog Novog već Odžaka. Potvrda već u tabeli naredne sezone. which referrs to Bosansko-sjeveroistočna zona 1970./71. in which Jedinstvo Odžak finished 2nd. I find it unusual that Jedinstvo Odžak isn't present in Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1968./69. even though it finished 4th in Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1967./68. We have no information on Jedinstvo Odžak playing in 1968./69. – Croxyz 💬 02:04, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I just realised that we have another table for Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1968./69. (F3 for 3 Jedinstvo, Odžak here). At the moment of writing our article states that Jedinstvo Brčko finished 3rd. This is false because Jedinstvo Brčko played in Druga savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1968./69. I'll correct it immediately. – Croxyz 💬 02:08, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I found more confirmation that Jedinstvo Odžak won Grupa A Prve zone 1969./70. Here we have:
- Kvalfikacije za popunu lige
- Učesnici:
- • Hajduk (Kula), prvaj Vojvođanske lige
- • Galenika (Zemun), prvak Beogradske zone
- • Valpovka (Valpovo), prvak Slavonske zone
- • Jedinstvo (Odžak), prvak Tuzlanske zona
- Hajduk (Kula) – Valpovka (Valpovo) 7:1 i 4:0
- Galenika (Zemun) – Jedinstvo (Odžak) 5:1 i 3:1
- and on an other post featured in the same link:
- 1 Jedinstvo, Odžak
- 2
- 3
- 4
- 5
- 6
- 7
- 8
- 9
- 10
- 11
- 12
- 13
- 14
- 15
- 16
- Viši rang: Jedinstvo (Odžak) je igralo kvalifikacije za popunu Druge savezne lige – Sever protiv Galenike i nije uspelo
- Ispali: ?
- Novi članovi: ?
- Napomene:
– Croxyz 💬 02:16, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)- Anyways, I fixed Grupa A Prve zone 1969./70. See if anything needs to be fixed on it.wiki for this and previous season (Jedinstvo Brčko -> Jedinstvo Odžak) – Croxyz 💬 02:30, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Cybermb I think Jedinstvo Odžak and Jedinstvo Novi Grad (I didn't know there was a Novi Grad in Odžak munioipality) are the same club. As to say Orijent Rijeka and Orijent Trsat.--Ame71 (razgovor). 14:52, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- In Druga savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1988./89. I hoped rsssf would have created the page. The cause of 3:0 for Bačka is at page 80 of this link.--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:02, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Ame71 & @Cybermb, Jedinstvo Odžak and Jedinstvo Novi Grad can't be the same club. In the incomplete 1985 club list Jedinstvo Odžak (under number 1) and Jedinstvo Novi Grad (under number 8) are listed separately under the Odžak section. Meanwhile, Jedinstvo Odžak featured in Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1960./61. and Međupodsavezna nogometna liga Brčko – Doboj – Tuzla 1961./62., while Jedinstvo Novi Grad played in Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1961./62. – Croxyz 💬 13:00, 29. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz and @Ame71, I wrote that,
- look again at Spisak ekipa koje su se postojale u nekadašnjem Brčko i Doboj savezu- 1985 sezona. - Odžak section - Jedinstvo Odžak is number 1, and Jedinstvo Novi Grad is by number 8.
- Stated Odžaks' clubs in 1985 are:
- 1 Jedinstvo Odžak
- 2 Strolit Odžak
- 3 Mladost Gornja Dubica
- 4 Jelen Trnjak
- 5 Bratstvo Gornji Svilaj
- 6 Mladost Donji Svilaj
- 7 Bratstvo Donja Dubica
- 8 Jedinstvo Novi Grad
- 9 Mera Vojskova
- 10 Napredak Srnava
- 11 Posavina Posavska Mahala
- 12 Polet Vrbovac
- 13 Novoselac Novo Selo
- 14 Omladinac Potočani
- 15 Borac Gnionica
- so Jedinstvo Odžak and Jedinstvo Novi Grad are not same club
- In book
- Bratislav Stojanović, Dragiša Kovačević: "Jugoslovenski fudbalski klubovi", Beograd, 1977., str. 1367
- there is information about FK Jedinsvo Novi Grad - founded in 1950 and (mid 1970s) playing in Grupna liga Doboj
- In book
- Iljo Dominković: Nogomet u Bosanskoj Posavini : 1920-1995, Orašje, 1996., ISBN 953-6432-18-8 (B - graf), str. 143
- for 1992. - NK "Jedinstvo" Novi Grad" - member of Općinska liga Odžak
- for NK Odžak 102 - I'm not sure is it same club (or it's legal continution) as Jedinstvo Odžak (playing during Yugoslavia), but as I wrote at my discuss page - Odzak 102 - played 1994./95. and 1995./96. seasons as Jedinstvo 102
- also, in Nogomet u Bosanskoj Posavini : 1920-1995 is not described connection between Jedinstvo and Jedinstvo 102, although there is a chapter about 1994/95 season
- Cybermb (razgovor) 17:11, 29. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz thanks for the infos. IMHO: not a great idea to call two clubs so close by the same name.--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:33, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Ame71 & @Cybermb, Jedinstvo Odžak and Jedinstvo Novi Grad can't be the same club. In the incomplete 1985 club list Jedinstvo Odžak (under number 1) and Jedinstvo Novi Grad (under number 8) are listed separately under the Odžak section. Meanwhile, Jedinstvo Odžak featured in Nogometno prvenstvo Jugoslavije – 3. ligaški rang 1960./61. and Međupodsavezna nogometna liga Brčko – Doboj – Tuzla 1961./62., while Jedinstvo Novi Grad played in Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1960./61. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Doboj 1961./62. – Croxyz 💬 13:00, 29. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- In Druga savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1988./89. I hoped rsssf would have created the page. The cause of 3:0 for Bačka is at page 80 of this link.--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:02, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Cybermb I think Jedinstvo Odžak and Jedinstvo Novi Grad (I didn't know there was a Novi Grad in Odžak munioipality) are the same club. As to say Orijent Rijeka and Orijent Trsat.--Ame71 (razgovor). 14:52, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Anyways, I fixed Grupa A Prve zone 1969./70. See if anything needs to be fixed on it.wiki for this and previous season (Jedinstvo Brčko -> Jedinstvo Odžak) – Croxyz 💬 02:30, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I just realised that we have another table for Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1968./69. (F3 for 3 Jedinstvo, Odžak here). At the moment of writing our article states that Jedinstvo Brčko finished 3rd. This is false because Jedinstvo Brčko played in Druga savezna liga Jugoslavije u nogometu 1968./69. I'll correct it immediately. – Croxyz 💬 02:08, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Grupa A Prve zone 1969./70. could've been won by Jedinstvo Odžak instead of Novi Grad although we don't have good sources. This site talking about Odžak states: U sezoni 1969.-70. Jedinstvo kao prvak „Tuzlanske zone“, igra neuspješno kvalifikacije sa FK „Galenika“ Zemun, za ulazak u II. saveznu ligu NS Jugoslavije. Iste godine momčad iz Odžaka osvaja titulu amaterskog prvaka BiH. Serbian wiki references this blogpost which states: Posle osvojene titule prvaka severne grupe Srpske lige,Galenici je do plasmana u severnu grupu Druge savezne lige preostao jos kvalifikacioni meč sa prvoplasiranom ekipom severne grupe Lige BiH,Jedinstvom iz Odžaka. Galenika je Jedinstvo pobedila i u Odžacima i u Zemunu i tako ušla na velika vrata u Drugu saveznu ligu. Sadly the history page on the club's website makes no mention of Jedinstvo. On the SportSport.ba forum I found: Tačna je i ispravka da Jedisntvo nije iz Bosanskog Novog već Odžaka. Potvrda već u tabeli naredne sezone. which referrs to Bosansko-sjeveroistočna zona 1970./71. in which Jedinstvo Odžak finished 2nd. I find it unusual that Jedinstvo Odžak isn't present in Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1968./69. even though it finished 4th in Tuzlanska nogometna zona 1967./68. We have no information on Jedinstvo Odžak playing in 1968./69. – Croxyz 💬 02:04, 28. rujna 2024. (CEST)
Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine
[uredi kôd]I just wanted to inform you that Croatian articles Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1976./77., Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1977./78. and Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1978./79. contain faulty tables. I managed to fix Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1979./80. I haven't checked Italian wiki. I presume that at least some of these errors exist both on Italian and Croatian Wikis. – Croxyz 💬 01:13, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I also fixed Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1980./81. – Croxyz 💬 01:22, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1983./84. is also faulty. – Croxyz 💬 01:40, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1984./85. is incorrect. – Croxyz 💬 01:46, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Same with Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1986./87. For some of these seasons the tables matched, however I was scared of checking if the goal difference or no. of wins/losses is correct. FK Kozara's accidently repeated the table for 1984./85. in place of the 1987./88. so I couldn't have checked it. – Croxyz 💬 01:54, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Nor is Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine – Zapad 1989./90. Unfortunately, I don't think I will be able to make FK Kozara Bosanska Gradiška's table to assist you. I'll have to see which club is next. – Croxyz 💬 02:07, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyzlet me know when you'll fix all the tables, so I will make the same in it.wiki (i copied the tables from hr.wiki when I created the 3rd division seasons).--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:49, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Ame71, the issue is that tables from FK Kozara's website and Cybermb's books do not match, in other words they differentiate. Usually, the easiest way to tell which table is genuine is by checking points, seeing if the total number of wins matches the number of losses, if the total number of goals scored matches the total number of goals conceded etc. Most of the tables mentioned above fail these tests meaning that we can't tell which one is correct with certainty. Too bad there are no easily accessible official tables (published by leagues/federations etc.). When compared to Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina in digitalising newspapers, scientific articles and other types of media (access to information in general) which are usually used for Wikipedia citations. – Croxyz 💬 23:35, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- And the obvious factor: the war which left large damage to major urban centres where such football history data would be stored (e.g. Sarajevo, Mostar, Tuzla which has their own "zona" leagues). For example (if I recall correctly) there is no definitive answer to the question of what is the first football club from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Croatia, on the other hand, has an entire list of early clubs, presumably with the foundation dates/years of these clubs. – Croxyz 💬 23:49, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- I just remembered that I forgot to notify you earlier today that it seems that FK Jedinstvo Brčko ceased to exist two years ago (see today's edits). – Croxyz 💬 00:16, 1. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I plan on doing FK Omarska's seasons. The style of their tables is eerily similar to yours. Do you know the origin of this style? Is it mimicking your articles/SportSport.ba forum posts or did this style develop somewhere else? – Croxyz 💬 02:30, 1. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz yes, I took the style from SportSport.ba forum, as it's easier to write and easy to understand for a reader. In Prva liga seasons I used another style because there were more things to write (the European cups).--Ame71 (razgovor). 04:18, 1. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I plan on doing FK Omarska's seasons. The style of their tables is eerily similar to yours. Do you know the origin of this style? Is it mimicking your articles/SportSport.ba forum posts or did this style develop somewhere else? – Croxyz 💬 02:30, 1. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I just remembered that I forgot to notify you earlier today that it seems that FK Jedinstvo Brčko ceased to exist two years ago (see today's edits). – Croxyz 💬 00:16, 1. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- And the obvious factor: the war which left large damage to major urban centres where such football history data would be stored (e.g. Sarajevo, Mostar, Tuzla which has their own "zona" leagues). For example (if I recall correctly) there is no definitive answer to the question of what is the first football club from Bosnia and Herzegovina. Croatia, on the other hand, has an entire list of early clubs, presumably with the foundation dates/years of these clubs. – Croxyz 💬 23:49, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Ame71, the issue is that tables from FK Kozara's website and Cybermb's books do not match, in other words they differentiate. Usually, the easiest way to tell which table is genuine is by checking points, seeing if the total number of wins matches the number of losses, if the total number of goals scored matches the total number of goals conceded etc. Most of the tables mentioned above fail these tests meaning that we can't tell which one is correct with certainty. Too bad there are no easily accessible official tables (published by leagues/federations etc.). When compared to Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina in digitalising newspapers, scientific articles and other types of media (access to information in general) which are usually used for Wikipedia citations. – Croxyz 💬 23:35, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyzlet me know when you'll fix all the tables, so I will make the same in it.wiki (i copied the tables from hr.wiki when I created the 3rd division seasons).--Ame71 (razgovor). 15:49, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Nor is Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine – Zapad 1989./90. Unfortunately, I don't think I will be able to make FK Kozara Bosanska Gradiška's table to assist you. I'll have to see which club is next. – Croxyz 💬 02:07, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Same with Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1986./87. For some of these seasons the tables matched, however I was scared of checking if the goal difference or no. of wins/losses is correct. FK Kozara's accidently repeated the table for 1984./85. in place of the 1987./88. so I couldn't have checked it. – Croxyz 💬 01:54, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1984./85. is incorrect. – Croxyz 💬 01:46, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
- Republička nogometna liga Bosne i Hercegovine 1983./84. is also faulty. – Croxyz 💬 01:40, 30. rujna 2024. (CEST)
Željezničar seasons from the early 20s
[uredi kôd]Previously I've mentioned that I've found a book about FK Željezničar Sarajevo. I did a brief check on it.wiki and found that early season from the 1920s and 1946 are missing (I only looked for links, I didn't check if already existing seasons had incomplete tables or none at all). Do you know Cyrillic? If not I could help you transcribe the tables. – Croxyz 💬 20:51, 3. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz mmmh, no, I can't read cyrillic... About Željezničar history I know this link. For the seasons from 1918 to 1941 it would be good to have this book.--Ame71 (razgovor). 05:17, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I compared the tables from your link's 1921/22 season to the same table in the Cyrillic book (page 30) and they don't match. – Croxyz 💬 10:20, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- 1922/23, 1923/24, 1924/25, 1295/26 seasons also doesn't match. – Croxyz 💬 10:25, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I didn't check if the tables from the Cyrillic books match with the already existing tablespre-WW2 tables on Italian Wiki. The 1945/46 table on page 2 of the forum link matches with the one on page 76 of the book, however the forum fails to list the matches on page 74: Sloboda vs Udarnik, Željezničar vs Udarnik, Sloboda vs Željezničar. It also notes (same page) that Gradski fiskulturni odbor decided on Februry 12 1946 to nullify the results of three autumn (the ones I mentioned) games and that a new city championship (Prvenstvo grada Sarajeva) should be held in March 1946. I also forgot to mention that I didn't compare the players list from the 1920s seasons. – Croxyz 💬 10:35, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- That 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship is featured as Južna skupina in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47.#Bosna i Hercegovina, although it doesn't mention the nullified 1945 matches. It would be good to turn the "text tabels" into actual wikitables for that season, mainly because it isn't not possible to access these seasons from the "Puntano qui" link on club articles. – Croxyz 💬 10:41, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- As for pre-WW2 seasons, this book contains a lot of them. I remember finding more pre-WW2 seasons on Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. Maksimir's seasons are missing. – Croxyz 💬 10:47, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Same for seasons of leagues played in Rijeka (Fiume). Results of Pre-WW2 Vojvodina mathces exist. I didn't check for numerous Vrbas clubs, Crikvenica nor the books on Slovenian football. – Croxyz 💬 11:02, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- In the evening I might compare the sources to this list on Željezničar’s site. I could probably even turn that list into a large wikitable within an hour (I’d probably need another one to add and find all the article names). – Croxyz 💬 11:55, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- It will be possible. It'll just take a lot of time. It'll expand Željezničar's article by around 65 thousand bytes. – Croxyz 💬 20:00, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I keep forgetting to add information about the 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship. I might do it tomorrow if i remember. – Croxyz 💬 00:55, 10. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Currently I'm wikipedifying Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. (switching plain text to tables, adding links to articles, calculating "kvoc."). I haven't added the 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship yet. It seems that RSSSF records more missing Croatian competitions/results. I haven't checked RSSF for other parts of Yugoslavia. Articles in Kategorija:Hrvatska nogometna natjecanja - sezona 1945./46. require cleaning (especially Prvenstvo grada Splita 1946.) These articles contain even more missing results (e.g. Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. doesn't mention the two preliminary competitions in Prvenstvo Zagreba u nogometu 1946.) There is no mention of Nogometno prvenstvo grada Osijeka 1946. whatsoever in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Do you plan on redoing the article? – Croxyz 💬 23:00, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- There's also it:Qualificazioni alla Hrvatska liga 1946 which includes an incomplete table for Nogometno prvenstvo grada Osijeka 1946. I didn't compare it to RSSSF so i don't know if anything is missing. Also I haven't checked Italian Wiki for other parts of Yugoslavia. – Croxyz 💬 23:10, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Doing Bosnia and Herzegovina at the moment. I checked yoour source [32] and I can see that it contains missing results for Bosnia and Herzegovina, as well for other parts of Yugoslavia. "Sjeverni dio" (Northern part) and "Južni dio" (Southern part) seem strange to me (see earlier messages). – Croxyz 💬 23:26, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I'll go to bed soon so I can't research these names today. I stumbled upon this source which I'll use to try and expand some Bosnia and Herzegovina seasons from the 1950s. – Croxyz 💬 23:57, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- The naming confusion doesn't end there. FK Željezničar's official website calls Velež Mostar the winner of Mostar region and Borac the winner of Banja Luka region (U razigravanju smo odmjerili snage sa pobjednicima drugih regionalnih takmičenja u BiH, tj. sa pobjednikom banjalučke regije Borcem i pobjednikom mostarske regije Veležom.). The Cyrillic book (page 77) also names Borac as the winner of the Northern Group (similarly to claudionicoletti.eu/'s Northern part), however it refers to Velež as the winner of the Southern Group, as opposed to claudionicoletti.eu's "Herzegovina". claudionicoletti.eu instead calls the Sarajevo City Championship the Southern Group. – Croxyz 💬 16:15, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I think we'll have to wait for the Internet Archive to see what's written in exyufudbal. On Ligaški vremeplov I found the same naming scheme as in the Cyrillic book. – Croxyz 💬 16:24, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I see Wayback Internet Archive is under hacker attack: no good for us.... --Ame71 (razgovor). 17:11, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Yep. Been like that these past few days. It happened while I was doing NK Svačić Stari Slatnik's table. – Croxyz 💬 17:16, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- At the moment I'm adding links to Vojvodina clubs in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Are you sure that Jedinstvo Senta is FK Senta and Radnički Inđija FK Inđija? – Croxyz 💬 17:34, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I couldn't figure out any Vojvodina club so I started fixing Serbia. I see that Italian wiki again has information not mentioned on Croatian wiki, this time in it:Qualificazioni alla Srpska liga 1946. – Croxyz 💬 17:47, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz Now I'm not so sure. When I created the pages I thought Senta and Inđija were the clubs I was looking for beacuse there weren't others... --Ame71 (razgovor). 17:57, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- The clubs appear in Prvenstvo Srbije u nogometu 1947./48., Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1947./48., Sjeverna grupa Srpske nogometne lige 1946./47. I don't know if there are more dubious clubs. – Croxyz 💬 19:02, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I'm checking all of the clubs from those seasons. Omladinac Kragujevac from Prvenstvo Srbije u nogometu 1947./48. can't be FK Zastava Kragujevac because FK Zastava Kragujevac was founded almost three decades later. – Croxyz 💬 21:48, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Can you find anything on Proleter Pirot being FK Radnički Pirot,
- Bratstvo Đakovica being KF Vëllaznimi Đakovica and Željezničar Kosovo Polje being KF Fushë Kosova? The last two are from Kosovo, so it is possible that they are translations. – Croxyz 💬 21:58, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz If you find something wrong you have to change. Clubs in YU changed more times their name, this is very strange for us Italians. And in DDR and Czechoslovakia was worst: some clubs have 8 changed names in their history. This is tipical of countries under communism. Creating sport pages in it.wiki is easier.--Ame71 (razgovor). 22:29, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I'm thinking it's better if you work the 3rd YU division pages. I'm not mothertongue and I can make 1st and 2nd rang, but doing the same for 3rd one I see it's too much for my skills (there are too many sites to check, too many names, complicated rules and changes, lots of datas impossible to find).--Ame71 (razgovor). 22:29, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I'll try and find confirmation for those clubs later. I managed to uncover every Serbian club from Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. except Borac Beograd. I already wrote every Croatian and Bosnia and Herzegovinian 3rd division season I could find from sites on Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. I never really tried searching for Montenegro, Vojvodina and Serbia. The way I found all these websites listed on Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori is by searching the name of competition in all grammatical cases. For example, yesterday I searched for Snaga Mostar from Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. I googled "Snaga Mostar" 1946. By putting Snaga Mostar in "" Google only gave me results that specifically used the phrase Snaga Mostar. I found that it competed in Mostarski potsavez (or in modern Croatian podsavez). I searched for "Mostarski podsavez" (and potsavez) in all grammatical cases and found this website which I used to expand Podsavezna nogometna liga Mostar 1952. For each competition I usually get anywhere from 0 to 2 useful results depending on how long it existed and its stage on the league pyramid. If you take a closer look at Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori you'll mostly find small groups of clubs that played in the same league at one point (or in other words they are really close). An example would be the tiny region of Međimurje which managed to feature 4 times (although some of these were found by Cybermb) while Istrian and Dalmatian (ignoring Hajduk and OSK Otok which only features seasons after the breakup of Yugoslavia) clubs did not feature at all! The reason I mentioned Montenegro, Vojvodina and Serbia previously is due to them having either a large number of leagues of which Italian Wiki rarely has a lot of information or due to their languages being written both in Cyrillic and Latin making it harder to find useful information on Google. Slovenia, Kosovo and Macedonia face the language barrier. I know that this exists for Macedonia however I don't really know how much of these seasons are covered on Croatian Wiki. I never tried searching for RSSSF tables for parts of Yugoslavia besides Croatia. Keep in mind that at least half of the club website links from Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori were found from your and Cybermb's articles on Croatian Wiki. I highly doubt that there are more than 5 still uncovered club websites for Croatia and Bosnia and Herzegovina. You can always translate the various lower leagues from Italian Wikipedia, do pre-WW2 leagues. In case you want to coversomething that isn't covered on Croatian and Italian Wikipedias, and is easy for you to understand and create, I suggest:
- a) Taking a look at various pre-WW2 seasons I posted in this discussion previously
- b) This one season (If I recall correctly Ligaški vremeplov contains tables for other groups of that same season)
- c) NK Polet Sveti Martin na Muri seasons from 1965 to 1984.
- d) NK Hajduk Brezje seasons from 1962 to 1991
- e) every single FK Omarska season. Serbian Wikipedia contains tables for every post-Yugoslavia season. These tables need to be added to various articles from 2002 to 2021.
- There are also several seasons from various lower leagues that are linked on Cybermb's talk page with which I have problems, mostly the competition names. Cybermb will hopefully manage to uncover at least some of these somewhere in the future. – Croxyz 💬 23:32, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- By the way I fixed the entire Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. article. All that's needed is to add the various matches/missing leagues from RSSSF, Italian Wiki, Kategorija:Hrvatska nogometna natjecanja - sezona 1945./46. articles and sources used in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Would you be interested in (partially) expanding the article? I'll try and see if I can find those club names (Jedinstvo Senta and others). If not I'll remove them. – Croxyz 💬 23:40, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- RSSSF also has Slovenian and Montenegrin tables. – Croxyz 💬 00:21, 13. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I just wanted to notify you that the Internet Archive is back although it's really slow for me. – Croxyz 💬 00:50, 15. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz It's very good, Internet Archive is plenty of sources good for us!--Ame71 (razgovor). 01:00, 15. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Yeah. It's running okay right now. I managed to complete all of the Serbian competitions/matches in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Currently I'm doing Zagreb. – Croxyz 💬 01:06, 15. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz It's very good, Internet Archive is plenty of sources good for us!--Ame71 (razgovor). 01:00, 15. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I just wanted to notify you that the Internet Archive is back although it's really slow for me. – Croxyz 💬 00:50, 15. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- RSSSF also has Slovenian and Montenegrin tables. – Croxyz 💬 00:21, 13. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- By the way I fixed the entire Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. article. All that's needed is to add the various matches/missing leagues from RSSSF, Italian Wiki, Kategorija:Hrvatska nogometna natjecanja - sezona 1945./46. articles and sources used in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Would you be interested in (partially) expanding the article? I'll try and see if I can find those club names (Jedinstvo Senta and others). If not I'll remove them. – Croxyz 💬 23:40, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I'm checking all of the clubs from those seasons. Omladinac Kragujevac from Prvenstvo Srbije u nogometu 1947./48. can't be FK Zastava Kragujevac because FK Zastava Kragujevac was founded almost three decades later. – Croxyz 💬 21:48, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- The clubs appear in Prvenstvo Srbije u nogometu 1947./48., Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1947./48., Sjeverna grupa Srpske nogometne lige 1946./47. I don't know if there are more dubious clubs. – Croxyz 💬 19:02, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz Now I'm not so sure. When I created the pages I thought Senta and Inđija were the clubs I was looking for beacuse there weren't others... --Ame71 (razgovor). 17:57, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I couldn't figure out any Vojvodina club so I started fixing Serbia. I see that Italian wiki again has information not mentioned on Croatian wiki, this time in it:Qualificazioni alla Srpska liga 1946. – Croxyz 💬 17:47, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- At the moment I'm adding links to Vojvodina clubs in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Are you sure that Jedinstvo Senta is FK Senta and Radnički Inđija FK Inđija? – Croxyz 💬 17:34, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Yep. Been like that these past few days. It happened while I was doing NK Svačić Stari Slatnik's table. – Croxyz 💬 17:16, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I see Wayback Internet Archive is under hacker attack: no good for us.... --Ame71 (razgovor). 17:11, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I think we'll have to wait for the Internet Archive to see what's written in exyufudbal. On Ligaški vremeplov I found the same naming scheme as in the Cyrillic book. – Croxyz 💬 16:24, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- The naming confusion doesn't end there. FK Željezničar's official website calls Velež Mostar the winner of Mostar region and Borac the winner of Banja Luka region (U razigravanju smo odmjerili snage sa pobjednicima drugih regionalnih takmičenja u BiH, tj. sa pobjednikom banjalučke regije Borcem i pobjednikom mostarske regije Veležom.). The Cyrillic book (page 77) also names Borac as the winner of the Northern Group (similarly to claudionicoletti.eu/'s Northern part), however it refers to Velež as the winner of the Southern Group, as opposed to claudionicoletti.eu's "Herzegovina". claudionicoletti.eu instead calls the Sarajevo City Championship the Southern Group. – Croxyz 💬 16:15, 12. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I'll go to bed soon so I can't research these names today. I stumbled upon this source which I'll use to try and expand some Bosnia and Herzegovina seasons from the 1950s. – Croxyz 💬 23:57, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Currently I'm wikipedifying Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. (switching plain text to tables, adding links to articles, calculating "kvoc."). I haven't added the 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship yet. It seems that RSSSF records more missing Croatian competitions/results. I haven't checked RSSF for other parts of Yugoslavia. Articles in Kategorija:Hrvatska nogometna natjecanja - sezona 1945./46. require cleaning (especially Prvenstvo grada Splita 1946.) These articles contain even more missing results (e.g. Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. doesn't mention the two preliminary competitions in Prvenstvo Zagreba u nogometu 1946.) There is no mention of Nogometno prvenstvo grada Osijeka 1946. whatsoever in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47. Do you plan on redoing the article? – Croxyz 💬 23:00, 11. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I keep forgetting to add information about the 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship. I might do it tomorrow if i remember. – Croxyz 💬 00:55, 10. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- It will be possible. It'll just take a lot of time. It'll expand Željezničar's article by around 65 thousand bytes. – Croxyz 💬 20:00, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- In the evening I might compare the sources to this list on Željezničar’s site. I could probably even turn that list into a large wikitable within an hour (I’d probably need another one to add and find all the article names). – Croxyz 💬 11:55, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- Same for seasons of leagues played in Rijeka (Fiume). Results of Pre-WW2 Vojvodina mathces exist. I didn't check for numerous Vrbas clubs, Crikvenica nor the books on Slovenian football. – Croxyz 💬 11:02, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- As for pre-WW2 seasons, this book contains a lot of them. I remember finding more pre-WW2 seasons on Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. Maksimir's seasons are missing. – Croxyz 💬 10:47, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- That 1945/46 Sarajevo City Championship is featured as Južna skupina in Kvalifikacije za Prvu saveznu ligu 1946./47.#Bosna i Hercegovina, although it doesn't mention the nullified 1945 matches. It would be good to turn the "text tabels" into actual wikitables for that season, mainly because it isn't not possible to access these seasons from the "Puntano qui" link on club articles. – Croxyz 💬 10:41, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I didn't check if the tables from the Cyrillic books match with the already existing tablespre-WW2 tables on Italian Wiki. The 1945/46 table on page 2 of the forum link matches with the one on page 76 of the book, however the forum fails to list the matches on page 74: Sloboda vs Udarnik, Željezničar vs Udarnik, Sloboda vs Željezničar. It also notes (same page) that Gradski fiskulturni odbor decided on Februry 12 1946 to nullify the results of three autumn (the ones I mentioned) games and that a new city championship (Prvenstvo grada Sarajeva) should be held in March 1946. I also forgot to mention that I didn't compare the players list from the 1920s seasons. – Croxyz 💬 10:35, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- 1922/23, 1923/24, 1924/25, 1295/26 seasons also doesn't match. – Croxyz 💬 10:25, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- I compared the tables from your link's 1921/22 season to the same table in the Cyrillic book (page 30) and they don't match. – Croxyz 💬 10:20, 4. listopada 2024. (CEST)
Predložak:Crnogorska republička nogometna liga
[uredi kôd]I don't know if you have noticed that I added the Predložak:Crnogorska republička nogometna liga template in FR Yugoslavia 2nd divison (Druga liga Srbije i Crne Gore u nogometu) season articles. Should that template be featured in Nogometno prvenstvo Srbije i Crne Gore – 2. ligaški rang 2004./05. and Nogometno prvenstvo Srbije i Crne Gore – 2. ligaški rang 2005./06.? For those two season the template contains links to Prva crnogorska nogometna liga articles, as opposed to Druga liga Srbije i Crne Gore u nogometu articles. I didn't know what links to add for seasons spanning from 1991 to 2006 so I left them blank. Should 2004./05. and 2005./06. be removed from that row? – Croxyz 💬 19:36, 23. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz I noticed there were a new template in the Druga liga SCG pages, and I agree. In 2004./05. and 2005./06. seasons the Montenegrin leagues were called "Prva crnogorska nogometna liga", I don't know if we can consider it as prosecutor of "Crnogorska republička nogometna liga" for 2 seasons (since 2006 it became top level). I've a doubt: Crnogorska republička liga was 3. rang in 2003./04., but I don't know if in the following seasons kept that name, or changed it in "Druga crnogorska nogometna liga".Ame71 (razgovor). 20:09, 23. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- RSSSF [[33][34] doesn't mention its name. It only mentions the name of the three groups (Južna, Srednja and Severna grupa) which made up the league. – Croxyz 💬 20:21, 23. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- @Croxyz In en.wiki, "Crnogorska republička nogometna liga" is considered till 2006, not just 1991. And they consider just the 3rd rang ones, so the seasons from 2000 to 2006 wouldn't be right to insert as template in Druga liga SCG (IMHO).Ame71 (razgovor). 12:20, 24. listopada 2024. (CEST)
- RSSSF [[33][34] doesn't mention its name. It only mentions the name of the three groups (Južna, Srednja and Severna grupa) which made up the league. – Croxyz 💬 20:21, 23. listopada 2024. (CEST)
Požega
[uredi kôd]Požega was called Slavonska Požega until 1991. This should be corrected on Italian Wiki in articles such as it:Zonske lige 1964-1965#Slavonia. – Croxyz 💬 13:30, 27. listopada 2024. (CET)
- Same for NK Požega -> NK Požega Slavonska Požega and NK Zvečevo Požega -> NK Zvečevo Slavonska Požega. – Croxyz 💬 13:39, 27. listopada 2024. (CET)
- @Croxyz I know (I found also Titovo Užice, Titov Vrbas, etc), but I think it's not important for a 3rd division page in it.wiki. If i created a single page (like Slavonska nogometna zona 1964./65.), I added the map and the real name of the towns and of the clubs, of course.Ame71 (razgovor). 13:55, 27. listopada 2024. (CET)
Podsavezna prvenstva
[uredi kôd]@Ame71, za ovo
- Slovensko podsavezno nogometno prvenstvo 1959./60. i
- Podsavezno prvenstvo Crne Gore u nogometu 1959./60.
je si li mogao za svaki podsavez zasebno napraviti ljestvicu kao što sam ja svojevremeo počeo, kao u člancima Podsavezna nogometna liga Maribor 1960./61. ili Prvenstvo nogometnog podsaveza Kotor 1960./61., odnosno možeš vidjeti po kategorijama Slovenska nogometna natjecanja po sezonama (1945. – 1991.) i Crnogorska nogometna natjecanja (1945. – 1991.)
ok, recimo zbog veličine je za Sloveniju ili Crnu Goru (posebno) tako lakše raditi, ali recimo imamo
- Međupodsavezna nogometna liga Maribor – Murska Sobota 1962./63. pa ispod podsavezne lige
Cybermb (razgovor) 19:25, 16. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb, rađe mu piši na engleskom jer je Talijan. Mislio sam ja spojiti te članke u 1 nakon što ih sve napiše. Mislim da zna da imamo Predložak:Sezone 4. stupnja nogometnog prvenstva FNRJ/SFRJ. – Croxyz 💬 19:29, 16. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- @Cybermb i @Croxyz nema problema s jezikom, tu je Google translate. Imajući samo ljestvicu, bez ikakvih drugih informacija, činilo se ispravnim grupirati prvenstva umjesto stvaranja jedne stranice za svako od njih. Znam Predložak 4. reda: ja sam ga stvorio.Ame71 (razgovor). 08:21, 17. studenoga 2024. (CET)
Macedonian league 1953/54
[uredi kôd]I've finally managed to uncover something for Macedonia. Sadly it's an incorrect table. It's here. Tikveš should have 30 instead of 38 points. The goal difference is also wrong (490:486). The number of losses is correct, unlike on English Wikipedia (en:1953–54 Macedonian Republic League) where the goal difference is also wrong (483:486). The site may contain complete tables elsewhere. I didn't manage to find any and I took a brief look. Did you manage to uncover the 1950/60 Croatian and Serbian tables in the end? – Croxyz 💬 14:23, 17. studenoga 2024. (CET)
Missing Montenegro tables i've found
[uredi kôd]So I've finally managed to find an online source on Montenegro football history (Serbian Wikipedia). I've added it (a series of 20+ articles) to Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori. Here is a list of newfound information:
- Prvenstvo nogometnog podsaveza Titograd 1963./64. (see Prvenstvo nogometnog podsaveza Titograd 1962./63.). Goal difference 84 != 83. Source: [35]
- Prvenstvo nogometnog podsaveza Titograd 1965./66. Goal difference 411 != 405. Source: [36]
- Južna nogometna regija 1978./79. ("Južna fudbalska regija" in Serb./Monte., literally Southern Football Region), a competition below Crnogorska republička liga and Titogradski pdosavez. Goal difference 275 != 274. Source: [37]
- Južna nogometna regija 1985./86., winner was promoted to Crnogorska republička liga next season. Goal difference 423 = 423. Source: [38]
- You've noticed on Italian wiki that Nogometno_prvenstvo_Jugoslavije_–_3._ligaški_rang_1989./90.#Međurepublička_liga_–_Jug has 2 different tables. HRnogometdb's table (it:Treća_Liga_1989-1990#Classifica_3) doesn't match with FSG Zrenjanin's points tally listed below. Sadly FSG Zrenjanin only mentions the points each club had. This source offers a third table. It doesn't match FSG Zrenjanin's points tally, however it's close. It isn't 100% accurate as the goal difference is 754 != 734. @Cybermb has access to a book about NK Neretva Metković (NK_Neretva_Metković#Statistika_natjecanja will probably needed to be changed) and archives of Sloboda Dalmacija, a newspaper that reported Dalmatian football results (Neretva Metković is a Dalmatian club), so he might solve this issue. There used to be a book about NK Vitez on isssu, however it has been removed and I can't view it on Wayback Archive. Maybe Cybermb has a copy?
- Nogometno_prvenstvo_Jugoslavije_–_3._ligaški_rang_1991./92.#Međurepublička_liga_–_Jug has a correct table unlike [39]
- Nameless competition from Montenegro 1992./93. (3rd rank or lower). Goal difference is 553 != 552. Source: [40]
- Južna nogometna regija 1998./99. Goal difference is 245 != 235. Source: [41]. Drogoplasirani “Arsenal” i trećeplasirani “Mornar” su igrali sa ekipama iz ostalih regija baraž za popunu crnogorske lige. Crnogorska seems to be a 3rd tier competition according to Druga liga SR Jugoslavije u nogometu 1998./99. and Druga liga SR Jugoslavije u nogometu 1999./00.
- I do not know if the following season (1999./00.) contains a missing match (15 are listed instead of 16).
- Republička liga Crne Gore 2000./01. Goal difference 946 = 946. Source: [42]. Third tier according to Druga_liga_SR_Jugoslavije_u_nogometu_2000./01.#Jug
- Druga_liga_SR_Jugoslavije_u_nogometu_2001./02.#Ljestvica_4 has a correct table unlike [43]
I stopped my research the year Montenegro got its independence. @Cybermb has several books on Montenegrin history as well. These books might cover the aforementioned seasons (and hopefully, contain correct goal differences). – Croxyz 💬 02:41, 18. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- A continuation of #Predložak:Crnogorska republička nogometna liga follows:
- The source, Barski portal, uses "Republička liga" for 1993./94., 1994./95., 1996./97., 2000./01. – Croxyz 💬 02:52, 18. studenoga 2024. (CET)
Kvalifikacije za Vojvođansku nogometnu ligu 1960./61.
[uredi kôd]I managed to uncover the Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1960./61. qualifiers. The table can be found here near the bottom left corner.
Source name: Somborske novine, godina VII, br. 324., 19 avgust 1960, str. 7.
I'll add this source to Suradnik:Croxyz/Izvori later.
1. Subotica
2. Mladost
3. Tekstilac
4. Potisje
5. ŽAK
I'm really confused. There's a club called ŽAK in Banatska nogometna liga 1959./60. (finished 5th) and Potisje in Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. (finished 4th). The qualifiers definitely aren't made up as firstplaced Subotica played in Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1960./61. The club didn't compete in Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1959./60.
Also, there's this article on Serbian wiki with full names of Podsavezna nogometna liga Sombor 1959./60. clubs. – Croxyz 💬 21:39, 21. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- I found clarification in Somborske novine, godina VII, br. 315., 17 jun 1960, str. 7. (under Ekipe ŽAK i Tekstilca podbacile...). The 5 participating teams are the top 4 clubs of Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. (Tekstilac Odžaci, Mladost Apatin, ŽAK Sombor and Potisje Kanjiža) and winner of Podsavezna nogometna liga Subotica 1959./60. (FK Subotica, not OFK Subotica, looks like a name change occured later on). I think this is what @Cybermb warned us about clubs from two different tiers participating in the same qualifiers. I might look for other club names later on (e.g. Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60.). Idk if there were any more qualifiers for Vojvođanska nogometna liga 1960./61. – Croxyz 💬 21:54, 21. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- I decided to call (O)FK Subotica Subotica in order to solve this naming issue. From Somborske novine I managed to extract every full club name of clubs participating in Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Subotica 1959./60. At the moment all that's left is the qualifiers table in Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Subotica 1959./60. I don't think there is information on any other qualifier groups. – Croxyz 💬 01:32, 22. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- I just did a review of every 1959/60 season in Godišnjak FSJ to see if anything is missing. Every Serbian podsavez is missing, Podsavez Čakovec and Dubrovnik in Croatia, Podsavez Kranj in Slovenia are also missing. During the day I’ll partition the Slovenian and Montenegrin articles with all Podsavez competitions into seperate articles for each Podsavez. – Croxyz 💬 02:22, 22. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- @Croxyz Ok for FK Subotica and the single subfederation pages from Slovenia and Montenegro. Now I'm keeping going with 3rd division 1967./68. Ame71 (razgovor). 07:04, 22. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- I just did a review of every 1959/60 season in Godišnjak FSJ to see if anything is missing. Every Serbian podsavez is missing, Podsavez Čakovec and Dubrovnik in Croatia, Podsavez Kranj in Slovenia are also missing. During the day I’ll partition the Slovenian and Montenegrin articles with all Podsavez competitions into seperate articles for each Podsavez. – Croxyz 💬 02:22, 22. studenoga 2024. (CET)
- I decided to call (O)FK Subotica Subotica in order to solve this naming issue. From Somborske novine I managed to extract every full club name of clubs participating in Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Subotica 1959./60. At the moment all that's left is the qualifiers table in Bačka nogometna liga 1959./60. and Podsavezna nogometna liga Subotica 1959./60. I don't think there is information on any other qualifier groups. – Croxyz 💬 01:32, 22. studenoga 2024. (CET)