Razgovor:Pravo

CIA Factbook // Legal systems

S obzirom na preusmjeravanje [[Pravni sustav]], koje preusmjerava ovdje, i zato što je ovo prazna stranica (koja se opet lako da obrisati) pišem ovo radije ovdje nego u Kafić. U Kafiću ću ostaviti kratku poruku o ovome, pa koga zanima može nastaviti razgovor ovdje.

Kako CIA Factbook gleda na pojedine pravne sustave

Država	Opis pravnoga sustava (engl. Legal system)
Hrvatska	based on Austro-Hungarian law system with Communist law influences; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Srbija	based on civil law system
Slovenija	based on civil law system; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Crna Gora	based on civil law system; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
BiH	based on civil law system; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Makedonija	based on civil law system; judicial review of legislative acts; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Kosovo	evolving legal system based on terms of UN Special Envoy Martti Ahtisaari's Plan for Kosovo's supervised independence
Kambodža	primarily a civil law mixture of French-influenced codes from the United Nations Transitional Authority in Cambodia (UNTAC) period, royal decrees, and acts of the legislature, with influences of customary law and remnants of communist legal theory; increasing influence of common law; accepts compulsory ICJ jurisdiction with reservations
Kuba	based on Spanish civil law and influenced by American legal concepts with large elements of Communist legal theory; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
DNR Koreja	based on Prussian civil law system with Japanese influences and Communist legal theory; no judicial review of legislative acts; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Poljska	based on a mixture of Continental (Napoleonic) civil law and holdover Communist legal theory; changes being gradually introduced as part of broader democratization process; limited judicial review of legislative acts, but rulings of the Constitutional Tribunal are final; court decisions can be appealed to the European Court of Justice in Strasbourg; accepts compulsory ICJ jurisdiction with reservations
SR Vijetnam	based on communist legal theory and French civil law system; has not accepted compulsory ICJ jurisdiction
Češka Republika	civil law system based on Austro-Hungarian codes; legal code modified to bring it in line with Organization on Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) obligations and to expunge Marxist-Leninist legal theory
Slovačka	civil law system based on Austro-Hungarian codes; accepts compulsory ICJ jurisdiction with reservations; legal code modified to comply with the obligations of Organization on Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) and to expunge Marxist-Leninist legal theory

Ni Ruska Federacija, ni države članice bivšega SSSR, niti sve države članice Varšavskoga pakta nisu ocijenjene "naljepnicom" komunistička, a od bivše SFR Jugoslavije, tom je oznakom netočno označena Hrvatska. Slaba je utjeha što su u istoj skupini Češka, Poljska i Slovačka.

Ja sam pisao njima u Factbook, nisam dobio odgovor, i ništa se nije promijenilo.

Bugoslav (razgovor) 23:30, 9. veljače 2010. (CET)

Ovdje je popis njihovih ocjena, a Rimsko pravo spominju nekim afričkim državama, treba pogledati zašto su Bugarska i Rumunjska u povlaštenomu statusu, kao i sve države članice bivše SFRJ (osim Hrvatske).

Bugoslav (razgovor) 23:45, 9. veljače 2010. (CET)

+ Dobro je da ih nisu ovdje citirali u potpunosti. -- Bugoslav (razgovor) 23:48, 9. veljače 2010. (CET)

Jedini način kako da se ovo ispravi je da se hrvatski pravni sistem pravilno obradi na ovoj wikipediji, kad se to učini ja ću uzeti zadatak na sebe da prevedem na engleskoj wikipediji. Sve je potrebno potkrijepiti sa dobrim izvorima. Vodomar (razgovor) 07:33, 10. veljače 2010. (CET)

Kozmetičke promjene

Kako CIA Factbook gleda na pojedine pravne sustave

Država	Opis pravnoga sustava (engl. Legal system)
Hrvatska	civil law system based on Yugoslav civil codes; note - Croatian legislation is changing the former Yugoslav legal model
Srbija	civil law system
Slovenija	civil law system
Crna Gora	civil law
BiH	civil law system; Constitutional Court review of legislative acts
Makedonija	civil law system; judicial review of legislative acts
Kosovo	evolving legal system; mixture of applicable Kosovo law, UNMIK laws and regulations, and applicable laws of the Former Socialist Republic of Yugoslavia that were in effect in Kosovo as of 22 March 1989
Kambodža	civil law system (influenced by the UN Transitional Authority in Cambodia) customary law, Communist legal theory, and common law
Kuba	civil law system based on Spanish civil code
DNR Koreja	civil law system based on the Prussian model; system influenced by Japanese traditions and Communist legal theory
Republika Koreja	mixed legal system combining European civil law, Anglo-American law, and Chinese classical thought
Poljska	civil law system; changes gradually being introduced as part of broader democratization process; limited judicial review of legislative acts, but rulings of the Constitutional Tribunal are final
SR Vijetnam	civil law system; note - the civil code of 2005 reflects a European style civil law
Češka Republika	civil law system based on former Austro-Hungarian civil codes and socialist theory; note - legislation is actively modernizing the legal system
Slovačka	civil law system based on Austro-Hungarian codes; note - legal code modified to comply with the obligations of Organization on Security and Cooperation in Europe and to expunge Marxist-Leninist legal system
NR Kina	civil law influenced by Soviet and continental European civil law systems; legislature retains power to interpret statutes; constitution ambiguous on judicial review of legislation
Mongolija	civil law system influenced by Soviet and Romano-Germanic legal systems; constitution ambiguous on judicial review of legislative acts

Vjerojatno im i ovo pomaže.

Nije čudo, kad pod Environment - current issues:

imaju, citiram: landmine removal and reconstruction of infrastructure consequent to 1992-95 civil strife

Tako je Hrvatska uz Kosovo jedina na svijetu koja ima jugoslavenski pravni poredak. Eto, nesvrstanih. Republici se Koreji pjesnički pripisuje kinesku klasičnu misao (čit. filozofiju; izvorno: Chinese classical thought). Poljska više nije komunistička, Češka je samo još malo socijalistička, a Slovačkoj još uvijek pišu marksizam-lenjinizam. Vrijedno je primijetiti što se zbiva s Kubom i Vijetnamom. Formula: Ulazak u EU da se zaštite njihovi interesi + navodno da ne budemo na zapadnom dijelu "poluotoka" (na koji nas ta ista EU birokracija et al. stalno smješta[ju].). -- Bugoslav (razgovor) 20:39, 9. rujna 2011. (CEST)